You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: Dec 14, 2019 9:40 am Title: Chapter 25: Checking My Pulse

I often had the feeling that Lindsay was enjoying her position between Mel and Brian and also liked Mel‘s jealousy of Brian. She didn‘t do anything against it. Not a nice character trait ... I like stories in which Mel and Brian overcome their differences and become some kind of real friends, they have the same kind of sarcasm.

This chapter. First of all, thanks for ending the story! I think I wrote it before... It‘s always hard to read an unfinished story when the story touches you so much. I also don‘t like these series where one season ends and then you‘ve to wait a year or longer. It ends at some exciting point, you can‘t stop to think about it for days or weeks, and then after one year, when you maybe have forgotten about it, not having this feeling any longer, they continue, and either you have to start over and get involved again, or you just don't have that feeling anymore. That's too bad. I think it's best when a story is finished and the author publishes a chapter from time to time, maybe once a week. but of course everyone has to know how to handle this. So, thanks for finishing!!!

One question... Did I understand this right? After Justin woked up for a few minutes, he fell again in this catatonic state and therefore they had to use ECT? Fortunately, it went reasonably well... I can‘t imagine how it feels not to remember things... I mean, we all forget over the years many many things, but something which happened only half a year ago or so...

„You sneezed your IV out." - haha - Although I've been working in the hospital for a long time, I've never seen anything like it. Only Justin can do that!

You - you called me sweetheart!" - Oh, a cute moment! Reminds me so much of this „You kissed me... in front of everybody?" You have this talent, to evake the same feelings in me which I get by watching the show, with just a few words. Incredible!

"It's just... you were so happy. When you found out, you were just so happy." - Oh, Jeez! That could refer to both the show and prom. But Justin knows there are enough other important, wonderful moments in his life that he can be thankful for! And maybe it is more important to cherish them and not to grieve after the forgotten moments. What a beautifful end!

I like this last chapter. Okay, it's described from Justin's point of view and therefore a bit more serious, melancholic than it might have been if you had written it from Brian's point of view. But I find that very appropriate at this point. All in all, a wonderful, loving story that doesn't change the characters, that is just perfectly written and has everything a story about Brian and Justin should have. A bit of fear and drama, but just as many sarcastic and hilarious ans also many beautiful and cute moments and a lot of love between the two! Thanks so much for sharing this story and I so hope to read something from you again sometime! I'll really miss our exchange! For now, all the best for you and your family!



Author's Response:

Yes, you understood correctly. The first course of treatment didn't work permanently so they had to use ECT. I wanted something that would interfere with Justin's memory just a little for exactly the reason you stated. Sure there are some happy memories he only gets to hear as stories (and also a lot of bad memories he doesn't remember too, so that's not so bad) but he gets more happy memories and he is still able to live a happy life. That's also why I had him say "this was the best night of my life" like he did at prom and Brian says "me too" rather than be sad. Brian is happy in the end too, despite or maybe because of all they have been through. 

Sneezing the IV out actually happened to my wife (she wasn't catatonic, she just had to have an IV) and it was so funny I couldn't help but include it. 

I too have been disappointed by WIPs that never finish. From the writing perspective, it's hard for me to write and not post while I'm in process. Some of it is my excitement to see what the reaction will be - a strong reaction motivates me - and the other part is that sometimes interactions with readers help shape what I'm writing. I'm writing in another fandom for now (I'll return to QAF, it's my first love) and I have everything outlined but as I'm writing, the characters, the readers shape the path. I'm still going to wind up in the same place but writing is a living thing and I think that's what makes fanfic different from purchasing a book. I love to read and the ability to interact with a writer WHILE they're writing a favorite book is like a dream come true. So I post WIPs and I read them and sometimes I'm disappointed (I hope never to disappoint others but you never know) but more often I get to live out what's a real fantasy for a bookworm. LOL I have voyeuristic tendencies when it comes to my favorite writers! 

Thank you so much for all your comments! It's been amazing getting to reread what I wrote along with you! Have a wonderful holiday season 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: Dec 13, 2019 5:32 pm Title: Chapter 24: Lying in Wait

Hi again! What a heartbreaking chapter! And poor Justin! I feel soooo sorry for him. All of a sudden, being reminded of his two worst moments in life in this moment when he thought this guy didn‘t use a condom and then this guy also raises his arm (his helplessness and fears, Sap‘s party, the bashing and Hobbs)... Oh goodness! Understandable that his brain turns off and he goes into this catatonic state...

And also poor Brian! "It is life-saving...he will leave me." Reading this, my heart really broke! It‘s so very well written and I think it was a really good idea to write this from Michael's perspective. How you describe through his eyes Brian‘s dispair, his fear, his struggle to keep it together, his love! That‘s so amazing.

And it's so good that Michael and Ben are there with Brian. He was partly on the verge of losing it. And again, I‘m glad, you change Michael in a much better version. He‘s a real best friend who for once knows what to do, how to behave, who recognizes what Brian needs. That‘s family!

„but who knows what kinky shit these two save for behind closed doors, like declarations of love." And although everything is so terrible, you made me smile with this...

...and then my heart broke again... „Tears rolled down his face and he whispered, "I'm sorry. I'm sorry." And what a absolut beautiful moment when you let Brian immediately see the changes in Justin. Awesome!

What‘s up with Jennifer and her behavior? She could have said „we are soooo glad" or „we were so afraid for you", but „you worried us"??? What the fuck. Totally wrong choice of words. I totally understand Brian's anger. Oh no, just one chapter left. I don‘t want this to end!



Author's Response:

It is a pretty horrific trauma and I felt so badly having to do it. 

I'm so glad you got the remark about it being life-saving for Brian, he wouldn't survive Justin leaving him, even if, in Justin's warped view it would be for Brian's own safety. 

I'm glad Michael's POV worked for this. I think Brian's own thoughts would not be as revealing as what his best friend is able to interpret from his expressions and body language. I imagine Brian in all this would just be a boring, not-detailed recap, so Michael's POV to the rescue!

The "kinky shit, like declarations of love" is just how I imagine Brian and Justin. Sure give all the public blow jobs you want but the sentimental stuff? That's private! 

Jennifer is...well I think she's being like a lot of us when we're worried. We're focused on ourselves rather than on how our behavior might impact the person we're worried about. She means well and, of course, truly loves Justin, but she is emotional and not thinking clearly. 

I'm sorry it will come to an end. Hopefully, you find it a good ending. The last chapter was so hard for me to write. I had real writer's block so I do feel ambivalently about it. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 13, 2019 1:37 pm Title: Chapter 23: Panic at the Disco

Hi again! It‘s really great to see, that Justin‘s doing fine in spite of all his issues! At least until this day... I feel very happy for him, that he successfully graduated and works in animation!

Unfortunately Lindsay will never change. she just can‘t leave it and has to make such careless (or not so careless - ?) comments. Fortunately, there‘s Mel who then makes up for it. Funny that you let her say nearly the same as Brian a few moments before!

Jeez, terrible how this really nice day ends. And how tragic that they‘ll now have to spend their anniversary day in the hospital again! Did you think about that while writing? Was it intended to happen that day?

„I looked at him again and he blinked. For whatever reason that clinched it for me" - Oh dear, Justin sends a cry for help in this terrible state and luckily Brian can understand him so well even in this situation.

Just two more chapters left... I feel already so sad!



Author's Response:

Thank you again for your thoughtful review! Yes, we are hurtling towards the end. 

Justin is doing well and I got to give him the job he said he wanted in 101, which made me very happy. 

Lindsay is... she has very specific ideas about life and people. I don't think it's intentional that her comments are insults dressed up like compliments but who knows. Mel is her saving grace. I've always thought Mel and Brian didn't get along both because Lindsay set them up to be jealous of each other (or at least Mel jealous of Brian) but also because they're too similar to really get along. 

It wasn't intended for the trauma to happen on their anniversary. Although I imagined this all went down after midnight. I needed it to happen in Pittsburgh and a few years later and I tried to think what would bring both Brian and Justin to Pittsburgh and Gus's birthday made sense. He hadn't been in much of the story so far so I also wanted to show Brian being a good dad. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: Dec 12, 2019 6:01 pm Title: Chapter 22: Family Planning

Hi again! „Michael - he's the jealous monster who lives in all of us" - that‘s a perfect description or definiton!

Do you know already the story „In quest of something" (ebbj9891)? Sometimes, they say I love you, but - in my opinion - not too often... It‘s such a great story, also funny, with angsty moments but also very often so cute and beautiful. I think, it‘s only published on „archive of our own".

By the way, Kinney is a great name for a cat and I‘m sorry about your loss. I‘ve lived together with two cats for about 17 years. They were really my roommates and for a long time my children. We were a „family" :-)

Again, what a perfect chapter! So beautiful and hilarious! The full Taylor-force! Poor Brian :-) It‘s great to see, that Molly and Brian are so comfortable around and with each other. „She followed me around... It felt very familiar." :-) And even better... „One Taylor will respect me in my home and the ship has sailed on that one" - magnificent! So many terrific moments! But who does Brian want to fool? He has completely under the spell of theTaylor family (except, of course, Craig). In them, he finally found the family he never had. And yeah,it‘s really a good idea to erase (most of) S5 from our memory. What I did love was this scene between Brian and Jennifer at the loft, when he told her about the proposal. I think, she really wanted Brian to be her son-in-law and I think that was not just because of their common preference of younger men...

Such a beautiful and cute moment when Brian takes care of both Taylors by massaging Justin‘s hand and painting Molly‘s toenails! And it‘s great how you let Justin explain the diffenrence between his passion for painting and love for animation.

„These Taylor kids were immune to all the "go away and leave me alone" vibes I had been perfecting for well over...let's just say a long time" - Oh, just thanks! You made me smile and laugh so much with this chapter!

Oh, and then this family discussion. I must admit, I also like mpreg-stories - it‘s fiction, so, who cares - some of them are so beautiful and well written... „I imagined those eyes on a kid and the way he was biting his lip like he was about to get in trouble, was just, I could just see it for a moment" - I think, that describes it in the best way, why I like those stories in which the have a child on their own (mpreg or one of them with a woman, but please not Lindsay!!!).

And I agree with Justin's dissatisfaction with the expression "start a family". Unfortunately, we humans have such fixed definitions for many things and you may only become more sensitive if you drop out of certain schemes. So, thanks so much for this amazing chapter!



Author's Response:

I do know "In Quest of Something" - I like it but I don't love it. Or, more specifically, there are parts I like and parts I don't. But overall it was such a fun series to read. 

Our pets are very much our family, so thank you for your condolences. :) 

Brian is powerless against the Taylor-trifecta (not Craig, obviously!). And he's not fooling anyone. They're the family he deserves. They love him but no one lets him get away with shit. At least in my imagination, Molly grows up to be just as smart and sassy as Justin and Jennifer. And yup, the scene where Jennifer says she wishes Brian would be her son-in-law is one of those few scenes in S5 that I can bear. 

There are so many stories I love where Justin or Justin and Brian have a child. It's been done so well. But here I wanted to express myself and my own decision to not have children through Justin. And, of course, my own frustration with the phrase "to start a family." 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 11, 2019 4:46 pm Title: Chapter 21: All Along

Hi! you really don't have to apologize for being delayed with answering. I really appreciate the exchange with an author, but I don't expect it, especially since I'm only reading the story now and not during the progress. Thanks for the many explanations about the mental health system. Mental health sounds totally interesting. I'm working in a neurosurgery department. Since I've got a lot to do with the functionality of the motor brain system, I've always wondered why Justin's right hand motor skills are disturbed when he'd got bashed on the right side... I really would like to ask this the authors of qaf.

Yeah, I agree with you, I also don't like Justin in relationships with other men so much, but it isn't so painful to read. Brian's ability to love just feels different, more unique - if he loves, it means everything. You've let him explain this very well! Either way, these relationships with other men may have a short purpose, but in the end, they should find each other again - for me, they just belong together. And I also really like to read stories with relationship issues, but what I like about your story, among other things, is that it's very clear that they belong together and have more to deal with other issues.

"There are so many secrets on the show (Brian visiting Justin, Sapp's party, etc) so I always like to see how those get revealed in fics." - Yeah, there were many topics in the show which - in my opinion - they sadly left unfinished. I also like it very much, when somehow these things come up again in stories.

Wonderful chapter! Michael... I've told you before that I have mixed feelings about him. Most of the time I disliked him, his behavior, his selfishness... So, I really like what you've done with his character. As I wrote before, he really matured, he can admit his mistakes, he accepts Brian's and Justin's love and I think one of my favorite sentences is this "I couldn't remember laughing that much anytime recently." And he really tries to take care of Justin. I mean, yeah maybe it was a little too much, telling Justin about the scarfing, but for me, his care feels honest and he didn't know about Justin being misdiagnosed. So, what Michael still has to learn is, not always assuming or judging, but in his defense, one could say that Justin and Brian aren't very communicative either, but that's what I love about them and their whatever it is. None of their friends really have the slightest idea how the two are with each other when they are alone... That's why I love this last paragraph very much ... Michael witnessing their welcome to each other... and how he experiences their home.

"I'm sorry, that's exhausting, huh?" - "You're sorry about the wrong thing here." Oh, I just love Brian!

"So Brian gave us his blessing this time?" - I love them both so much!



Author's Response:

I had never thought of that - of course, it makes no sense for him to be bashed on the right side of his brain and have functional impairements on the same side. Oh CowLip, they definitely didn't do a good medical consultation for that one. 

I don't mind stories with relationship issues when the issues are along the lines of "how can we make this relationship work better?" Too much else is just not fun for me to read and that's why I'm here after all! 

The show left so many things unanswered or in secret. In this chapter there's another secret revealed, whatever Brian did with the scarf. In the show his motives weren't entirely clear so I left it a bit open-ended here too. 

Michael - he's the jealous monster who lives in all of us. He wants to be happy for Brian and I think he genuinely likes Justin, but part of him can never let go of that childhood crush and hero worship. Poor Ben, is what I always think. He must have had the patience of a saint. 

"None of their friends really have the slightest idea how the two are with each other when they are alone" - that sums up why my favorite fics are those that are lots of domesticity while maintaining their characters (Domesticity with Brian saying "I love you" every other line? No thank you.) Also, I think in too many fics Brian keeps his persona too well erected when he's alone with Justin. I imagine them together alone there's kindness and compassion as well as a humor that no one else gets to see. 

I'm glad you liked the "You're sorry about the wrong thing here" line. It's one of my favorites. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 10, 2019 5:34 pm Title: Chapter 20: Text Me When You Get There

Hi! It's good to see the boys are getting a break. So some fluff is welcomed!

I would have loved to read more about this scene with Brian and the "four" kids :-)

"Ted just asked if I got you anything. Was I supposed to?" - that's so cute and so Brian! And I love that they don't care about those days - you let them show each other very often how much they love each other...

Getting off through - what do you call this? - text sex during a business phone call... haha :-)

What about Ru Kinney-Taylor? :-)

That was a great chapter and I really would have loved to read more of their beautiful, cute and funny moments, but even better is the fact, that Brian's finally more often at home again... But you let them be so beautiful together no matter what they do...



Author's Response:

Thank you so much! 

This one was fun to write but also a challenge because you know Brian and Justin aren't pouring their hearts out by text and so much of their communication is by action so the limitations made it a challenge. I'm glad I did it successfully. 

LOL I can't write Brian and Ted taking care of the kids - I don't know kids well enough to make it realistic. 

And I think it's called "sexting" haha. 

Ru would probably be Ru Taylor-Kinney. Ru is actually based on the cat my wife had when I met her whose name was...Kinney. I had never watched the show before and she got to introduce me. Kinney, the cat, has since passed. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 10, 2019 4:32 pm Title: Chapter 19: How to Survive

Hi! So, the first part of this chapter made me smile a lot. I just love Brian's sarcasm and humor. But what a shock for Brian and a realization for me... So, the OCD changed from violent thoughts into the fear to have been infected and therefore fearing to infect Brian... And it started in San Francisco and was triggered through the talk with Daphne. Poor Justin.

What's so crazy about it is, the way Brian describes their last six months, it sounds as if they were really good, really happy. To imagine that Justin was still constantly concerned about being infected and he was in fear the whole time ... and Brian didn't notice. Is it often the case that people can hide their obsessions and fears so well?

By the way... "Exiting Babylon each night, my eyes would be drawn to the lamppost" - I love this sentence!

"Mikey having to sign off as Justin's supervisor gave me endless joy." - Oh, I can imagine Brian's joy, makes me also laugh!

Brian's anger, his reaction is very severely, hurtful and at some point bordering on disrespect, but actually it shows only his own insecurity and his scary fear of losing Justin. I love the way you turn this argument into a good conversation. A few years earlier, either Brian would have run away, doing some pain-management, or Justin would have fled. But they are both matured, each for themselves and also with each other. Amazing! And it's very good that Justin talks about everything and tells Brian what happened almost at that time. And then, oh my goodness, can it really get worse? :-) Can't Justin get some good news?

"Buy Justin something pretty." - :-) Oh, that's so cute. I'm so in love with your Brian! "I figured you would want the underdog, er, undercat." - :-) And as I wrote before, nevertheless yo let him stay totally in character. But hopefully Justin won't develop cat allergy if he doesn't already have it! :-) And thanks again for sharing this fantastic, so well written story in spite of your anxiety! It's amazing!



Author's Response:

Reading that you like my Brian is the hugest compliment! He's the hardest character to write but also my favorite.

People can get away with hiding their OCD symptoms but Justin also didn't realize what was going on was OCD, until Brian confronted him, he thought he was just trying to be responsible. He was happy too, all those emotions can co-exist. Also, Brian and Justin have pretty independent lives so it would have been easy for Justin to get tested without Brian noticing (which is also why the testing stopped while they were back in Pitts because they were together all the time being on vacation rather than just daily life).

There are so many secrets on the show (Brian visiting Justin, Sapp's party, etc) so I always like to see how those get revealed in fics. 

Brian's reaction - worry often gets masked as anger especially for folks who are uncomfortable with emotions (ahem Brian). But his growth means he sticks with the conversation and doesn't go trick and get drunk and use drugs to avoid it. 

Don't worry - I wouldn't give Justin a cat just to take it away. I love some hurt/comfort but I'm not about having to surrender a rescued cat! That's too cruel. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 09, 2019 4:30 am Title: Chapter 19: How to Survive

Hi again! After reading this chapter everything became clear! Wow! And my mood ... Is actually quite easy to explain, I think. That was from written Justin's point of view and that this varies between happy and sad, is no wonder. A longer review will follow. But again in between: Thanks so much for this amazing story, so well written, you're really talented! Warmest regards!

 



Author's Response:

Thank you for the kind comments on my writing! So incredibly sweet and wonderful to read! I'll go check out your longer review.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 08, 2019 8:50 pm Title: Chapter 18: A Bridge

Hi again! What a strange chapter, there are many beautiful and happy moments, but at the same time while reading it, I sometimes felt a deep sadness and there were also some angsty moments. And I asked myself if I were in a dark mood while reading it or if this chapter evoked those feelings inside of me....

For example, the first scene at the backyard and Justin's thoughts about Brian... It seems to be so peaceful. And it's beautiful that Justin knew from the start that he was different and got these special moments with Brian, at the same time, he had to learn to be careful, how to behave, so that Brian wouldn't push him away. that's also a little bit sad I think.

Then this domestic partnership... I don't know, maybe I expected it to be a little bit more ridiculous romantic, but after giving it some thought, I came to the conclusion, that it was the perfect way to let them handle it. In fact, they don't need such a thing, but society forces them to do it to have equal rights... "I just don't want to ever feel like I can't get to you." And I love, that Brian combines this act with the suggestion to go to this exhibition and also Justin understands the meaning of this gesture - the real proof of his love - and that's what counts.

"I felt so safe beneath him like he was protecting me from the world" Like I wrote before, there are many beautiful moments in this chapter, but on the other hand Justin has this strange feeling that something bad will happen... Daphne's talking about barebacking... Justin's falling back in his worse behavior about checking the door... the nightmare about the Sap's party... the panic attack on the bridge... Was the panic attack on the bridge the bad thing that he feared would happen? And what I didn't understand: "Within an hour, I had my answer and felt better" What was he looking for? What did he find? Warmest regards!



Author's Response:

The back and forth between happiness and sadness was intentional here. Justin is grateful to be with Brian and to have their life but is also recognizing that this journey they're on with his mental health is long term and wonders if this is putting Brian in a role he will come to resent (he won't). 

My wife and I got a domenstic partnership in Los Angeles and it's really as romantic as a trip to the DMV or dentist. Plus I figured Brian and Justin wouldn't be sentimental (since I've erased S5 from my memory) about it. And yes, so right that the romantic part is Brian knowing there's an art exhibit that Justin wants to see. After all, marriage is a contract, love is knowing something will make your partner happy and trying to make sure it can happen. 

You'll see what happens in the next chapter (which I see you've already read) but yes I think recovery from anything isn't linear. As you said in a review before, two steps forward, one step back. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 08, 2019 10:32 am Title: Chapter 17: Sharp Turn

Hi! In my opinion, you absolutely let Brian stay in character and let him also develop, mature, grown up. And yeah, I totally agree, he loves Justin so much and that was often showed in the serie, in little gestures, in looks, when they kissed... On the other hand, there were often also so hurtful moments between them, also sometimes just in looks. But that's also what makes their whatever this is between them so interesting, so unique, so complex. I don't know. I'm absolutely crazy about them, as I said before, for me, they are the most beautiful couple in the whole film history. I don't know how Gale Harold and Randy Harrison managed this, this chemistry between them.

Oh, that's interesting that you work in mental health. Explains why you manage to write this so detailed and in such a sensitive way! I like the explanation that one of the reasons why Ethan happened was Justin's loss of the ability to understand Brian's non-verbal-communication. He really lost so much because of the bashing...

The beach scene. I haven't thought about prom, but that's a really beautiful thought!

This chapter... I know, I repeat myself, but I just can't help it, I love this chapter very much! Again, it's amazing and Brian's thoughts during this car-ride made me smile. "Now that I've signed up for it, he is absolutely not allowed to quit on me." And I've exactly the same view about their ability to have relationships with other people. That's why I can't stand or read stories in which Brian develops serious feelings or a serious relationship with other men, because for me, he represents this guy who only really loves once in a lifetime and that's Justin. And I can't imagine him getting involved in an average relationship. Regarding Justin I would say, he‘s able to fall in love more often or he has the ability to be in other relationships even if it's not the biggest love of his lifetime because that's not possible, because this place is already occupied by Brian. :-)

I've got a question, maybe it's my english... Justin has a therapist, Regina... Why has he now another psychiatrist? And oh goodness, give the poor boy a break! :-) I feel so sorry for him! We've read in chapter 4 the summarize of everything Justin's been through so far. Then he's misdiagnosed with depression and suffers through each day with violent thoughts and desperate fears. Then fortunately he found a competently therapist and gets finally the help he needs. Then the medication which helps him has these side-effects of losing his sex-drive and therefore he takes other medication which leads to a seizure... Again, who could blame Justin... Sex has always played an important role between them and I could understand if he would fear also a little bit Brian's reaction... Think about the cancer and how Brian behaved. But it's not only about Brian. Hey, Justin is around 22! Who would want to lose interest in sex at this age? What I really love here is, how you let them handle such issues together with fewer and fewer problems. Not only has Brian grown up, they also develop together as a couple in the right direction! And I'm sooo curious about the way Brian'll bring up the domestic partnership!! And by the way, great ending of an awesome chapter! :-) Warmest regards!



Author's Response:

Sorry about the delay in responding! Life has been hectic but I finally have a break at work. 

So the mental health system is confusing, even for someone for whom English is their first language. Therapists (psychologists, clinical social workers, marriage and family therapists) provide counseling but cannot prescribe medications. Psychiatrists have a medical degree and can prescribe medications (as can primary care providers, but it's always best to go to a specialist). In the US, at least, because of how insurance works, psychiatrists who take insurance are rare and those who do often just give 15 minute appointments beause  they need to see so many patients in one day to make enough money. Justin, being sensitive about money, went to a psychiatrist for his medications who took insurance and didn't get very good care (which would have been a much more thorough medical history). For treatment of many mental health disorders, especially those that are moderate to severe, the gold standard of treatment is usually counseling (CBT, like Justin is getting with Regina) and medication. 

I completely agree with you that Brian in a relationship with someone else always makes me upset. For all the reasons you listed and I wrote about (and will continue to write about) Brian will only ever be in a relationship with Justin. Justin, I think, could have a relationship with someone else but very rarely do I like it. And of course no relationship can compare to the great love that is Britin. 

Sexual side effects are one of the most common reasons people stop taking their medication! Justin is not to blame. He got poor care and that's not his fault. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 07, 2019 6:18 pm Title: Chapter 16: Exposure

Hi again! I really admire how you describe Justin‘s thoughts, his struggle and his dispair. I was curious and had to looked it up on wikipedia „In a study by Salman Akhtar (1975) the subjects of the obsessive thoughts of those affected were asked. The most frequently mentioned were:"... Next to others this was mentioned: „Violence and aggression (physical or verbal attack on yourself or others, accidents, mishaps, war, disasters, death)" I really didn't know that. Like Justin I thought, it would be mostly about the force to wash hands all the time or such things.

"the house Brian bought us in LA was the first place that felt like a home since I came out." - Wow, that's great and what I've hoped for Justin

It's so great to see Brian's onto Justin and sees right away that something is going on. And again, unsure of himself, he expected the worst. And I really can understand that he's hurt because of Justin's partially loss in trust in him or them, but who could blame Justin. Although he was really great after the bashing in helping and supporting Justin, there were so many moments when Brian pushed him away or expected Justin to assume things without revealing anything by himself. So, yeah, somehow he got this right "I've really fucked up" - It's so amazing to see how you let him grown up by letting him say things which Justin maybe would have needed to hear a long time ago (but I also understand that or why Brian wasn't ready to say such things at that time). "I would fucking tear the world apart for you." - Just beautiful!

I felt sorry for Brian, because with this reassuring and checking he thought, he would been helping Justin in some ways. But I'm also glad that he doesn't develop some kind of guilt about it. And I have to agree with Regina, Brian seems to be so natural at this. When Justin struggles so much later, he stays calm and finds other ways or exactly the right ways to help and support Justin! Amazing!



Author's Response:

Hi! Yes, the violent and aggressive thoughts are really common. I also work with a lot of straight people who have intrusive thoughts that they're gay, which is really fun to work with (probably weird to describe this work as fun but coming up with exposures like what happens in this chapter is like a puzzle). 

There is a podcast or something out there where they did a lot of research into PTSD and head trauma and learned (and this is correct) that people with those can struggle with reading non-verbal cues. So their headcanon, which I latched onto, is that in Season 2, Brian was great taking care of Justin but didn't realize that the Justin who "was onto him" wasn't functioing in the same way anymore. Brian communicates non-verbally so much of the time and Justin could no longer "speak that language" so to speak and that's where the Ethan episode happened. 

It can be really hard to learn that what you've been doing as a supportive partner has been making things worse, or at the very least not helping. But yes, Brian is such a natural care-taker that once he's pointed in the right direction, he's fully onboard and won't let Justin down. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 07, 2019 9:46 am Title: Chapter 15: Finding the Horizon

Hi again! One step a time... and a few backwards... There were so many beautiful and happy moments in the last few chapters that I almost forgot how sick Justin really is. I think every one of us knows these days, when you don't want to get out of bed or you wanted to do so much more than you did at the end of the day. And in the evening you are dissatisfied with yourself. But hey, that's only one day. I find the idea really terrible that it could go like this every day. And Brian is so sweet, so patient. I mean, yes, he's worried so much, but he has no expectations of Justin, he doesn't push, no pressure, he just loves him, he just tries to be there for him. "I am pretty sick of this caricature of me as Big Bad Brian waiting for the smallest excuse to ditch poor little Sunshine" - I love this, shows how much Brian has grown up! And how heartbreaking, when Justin reveals the truth about the guestroom. And I totally agree with Brian... without therapy, it'll probably get worse. So, I think, it's a good thing that Justin's going to therapy again and maybe a little pressure from Brian isn't so bad at all...

"trying to understand how someone like Justin Taylor is even of this world and how by some absolute mistake in this universe, he's chosen me" - Oh my goodness, I love your way of showing through those sentences how much and deeply Brian loves Justin. And that's really cute or crazy ... They both love each other so much and yet they both doubt and wonder why they deserve the other...

So OCD... To be scared all the time must be horrible. I feel so sorry for Justin. Hopefully this therapist is able to help him. I've little experience with depression and/or OCD. Does the depression results from the OCD or vice versa? Or are they two diseases, and he was misdiagnosed? Warmest regards!



Author's Response:

Gosh you know getting to read that you see Brian growing up but staying character as the best feedback I could receive. He loves Justin so much and I think we see that in the show when we're looking for it. But I like getting into his POV and all the thoughts he has about how to try to help Justin.

OCD is a tricky beast and usually misunderstood. The types of thoughts Justin was having are often overlooked even by trained professionals and diagnosed as suicidal or homocidal so unfortunately a lot of people are misdiagnosed. But anyone with moderate to severe OCD is going to be a bit depressed. OCD can really feel like a trap that makes our lives smaller because of all the restrictions intrusive thoughts place on our behaviors (Justin being scared to sleep in the same room as Brian) so depression is a reaction to that. This is the point that I should mention I work in mental health and OCD is one of my areas of specialty so it that was an inspiration for writing this fic. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 07, 2019 7:41 am Title: Chapter 14: Closer

After the previous much too long text, now something short :-)

I think I haven‘t mentioned it so far. I really like Ted. In the show, I was a little bit surprised about his role when Brian‘s got diagnosed with cancer, but it was a good surprise. Ted‘s really a great guy and I see him as a much better choice for a best friend. So, I like stories in which Brian and Ted develop a great friendship. And I felt very happy for Justin getting accepted at Cal Arts! That‘s a step in the right direction - so, one step at a time! ;-) And Brian‘s reaction is so cute! Oh, all these goodbye-speeches are heartbreaking... and again, you managed to portray all their characters so well!How I would have love to see this beach-scene in the show. As I mentioned before, your version of how it could have been in S5 is so much better! „genuine happiness written across his face" Makes me smile!



Author's Response:

I've always liked Ted. Just like I like Melanie. I have a soft spot for "nerds." And I loved how Ted and Brian's relationship slowly and quietly developed in the series. 

I also love the beach scene - I was hoping with Brian picking him up and spinning him around it would be reminiscent of prom...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 06, 2019 2:59 pm Title: Chapter 13: In Just Seven Days

Hi again!

Sounds like your stepmother‘s changed similar as Jennifer...? Luckily, at least your wife's father had a different point of view from the start. Otherwise it could have maybe been terrible different if that hadn‘t been the case... My eldest son started listening to Abba, Agnetha and the Rocky Horror Picture Show at the age of thirteen. Since he is not that typical boy, I sometimes thought, he may be gay. I'm still not sure, but by now I'd be almost disappointed if I didn‘t have a son-in-law at some point ... :-) No, it doesn‘t matter, the main thing is that he'll be happy!

S5 - Yeah, I also could have done without most of it. I got the impression Brian was totally thrown back through Justin‘s departure to LA. And then, after this short beautiful moment after the bombing, they moved too fast first in one direction, and then exactly too fast in the opposite... I‘ve just wrote it in another review... Sometimes I‘m glad, that there wasn‘t another season. Who knows what they would have done to these wonderful characters...

Lindsay: Fake is a good word, that‘s what I meant with „not real", and yeah, manipulative describes her also very well, I think that‘s what I wanted to say with sneaky.

I could also imagine Brian and Justin laughing a lot together. Since Brian seems more free and "wall-less" in Justin's presence, it's only logical for me that his often sarcastic humor (which I also love) turns into a carefree humor. I know the story "The One Where Justin Loses His Hearing" - but I haven‘t read it so far because of different reasons. First, I normally just read finished stories. I've had bad experiences too often in this regard. There is nothing worse than being totally in a story, and then this story won‘t be finished. But I think with this story it wouldn‘t be the case, because I noticed, that the chapters mostly have some kind of ending. The second reason is, that I‘m not sure, ehat I could endure seeing Justin being so sick. I‘ve read a little bit through the beginning it and I've stumbled upon this point when Brian says - I believe to Michael - that he's so upset he never told Justin that he loves him because now Justin won‘t ever be able to hear it again. This alone was so heartbreaking. But I think, after I‘ve finished your story, I‘ll give it a try.

So, but now, this chapter. An amazing conversation between Debbie and Brian. I really like how you handled all those characters which often caused mixed feelings for me.. Michael, Lindsay and sometimes also Debbie. So, it‘s good to read that she tells Brian how proud she‘s about him and his behavior.

Brian and Justin in LA. Amazing, again so many lovely details like „but it's like he just knows when I enter a room or even when I'm looking at him" (refering to chapter 11 :-) ). Or I also noticed, that Brian can call him Sunshine again without being troubled about it. The money problem - I can understand both of them... Justin, who has nowhere near the financial resources, and a guilty conscience, that Brian will continue to pay for mostly everything. Justin's fear that he might disappoint Brian and that he regrets it at some point. In the long run, I don't think this inequality is good for a partnership. Therefore, I wish Justin very much that he'll eventually earn money with his art. And Brian, who has the possibilities and only wants the best for himself and Justin. He just wants Justin to be happy and safe. And we've seen in S4, that's also very hard for Brian to accept help and/or money. So I think, he should understand Justin's point of view. But I'm glad, that they didn't cancelled their plans. Oh, and I love this "This kid, he's it for me" Great chapter, again, so many beautiful, cute, funny but also angsty moments! Thanks!



Author's Response:

Thank you again for such a lovely review!

The One Where Justin Loses His Hearing does have some difficult parts with him being sick but the author has an amazing sense of humor and captures the characters so well. And no one spends too much time being sad about Justin being sick. But you know yourself and what you enjoy reading. It's not a work in progress - as you mentioned each chapter has its own ending. The first 26 parts all string together and the rest are one-shots or short arcs within that universe.

Justin's concern about money is valid but for me the line in this chapter about no one earning the same amount as their partner was key. Each person contributes to a relationship, someone makes more money and someone else does something else. In the case of Brian and Justin - Brian has tons of money and it's one way he can show Justin how much he cares since he's still learning how to show it in other ways and Justin, well Justin gave Brian a life with love, which is pretty priceless. 

I love how accepting you are of your son. I was certainly into Rocky Horror when I was younger :) 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 05, 2019 5:09 pm Title: Chapter 12: Start Spreading the News

Hi! Another amazing chapter! Again, you‘ve made me laugh and smile so much! It‘s hilarious and perfect. The way you picture Brian, what he says, what he thinks, his gestures... There are so many details and sentences I love... First, this scene with Ted and the question after role-play :-) „Wait, you know what, I don't want that visual. Don't tell me." - that‘s Brian! It reminds me so much of the scene with Brian and Justin the first morning after. You characterized him so perfectly!

The scene with Micheal isN‘t only also perfect and funny but also beautiful. I really like Michael‘s reaction, because for once he reacts as a best friend should. Of course he'll be sad, but it's good to see, that for once he's thinking first of Brian. It‘s so beautiful, that he tells him how much he is happy for him, that he loves and is loved and that he deserves it! Michael has also grown up! In the show, I didn‘t really like Michael and there were many awful scenes, in which I just didn‘t get him, so I like both kind of fanfic, anti-Michael but also stories, where he develops and acts like a real good friend.

The reaction of Lindsay was more like I expected it to be. I never quite knew what to think of Lindsay - like Michael. I‘ve often felt that she supports the relationship of Justin and Brian and wishes for Brian to be happy. On the other hand, there were those moments, that annoying Peter, which more likely meant that she didn‘t want Brian to leave Neverland. And then there was Season 5.... so, no, I don‘t like her very much. I don‘t know how to say it in english, to me she always seemed to be not real.. kind of sneaky... „I hear they take owner surrenders at the pound. Unless you want him? He is housebroken." :-) your vision of Brian is fantastic! And then this „You move him" - Sometimes she really talkes about Justin more as a dog then a human being with an own mind... Good that Mel intervenes at the right moment!

And this conversation between Brian and Justin is so hilarious and soooo cute. How do you do this? They are sooo beautiful together! I could read this over and over!



Author's Response:

This was one of the most fun chapters to write so I'm glad you like it! I love humor in fics so I'm very glad my attempt at it landed.

I'm not the biggest Michael fan - he's immature and his relationship with Brian...well I think they both share responsibility in that. But I love character growth and I feel like Michael had the potential to develop into a good guy. In some later chapters, you'll get his POV.

I dislike Lindsay so much though. Ugh. She's fake and manipulative and so selfish with Brian and anything or anyone else she considers "hers." I adore Melanie though so she will always come to the rescue whenever Lindsay is being herself. Is the word you're looking for "superficial" or "fake" for Lindsay? 

I love imagining what Justin and Brian are like when no one else sees them and I imagine they laugh a lot. Brian doesn't get to just joke around with anyone else, only make fun of them. 

Honestly, if you are enjoying what I write, I was/am incredibly inspired by The One Where Justin Loses His Hearing by LaVieEnRose. It's partially posted here but it's in its entirety on Archive of Our Own: https://archiveofourown.org/series/1026162 If you haven't read it, I'm actually jealous you get the enjoyment of reading it for the first time. I've read it several times over. 

 

 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 03, 2019 7:15 pm Title: Chapter 11: This is Not That Kind of Love Story

Home: I was sorry about what you wrote about your wife. I‘ve to admit, I‘m a „breeder", but I try to support my lesbian friend and also go to the CSD and other events with her every year. I‘ve two sons myself and if one or both would be gay ... it wouldn‘t matter at all. I don‘t know, I guess, I just grew up differently. I recently saw a report about conversionscamps. It was scary. I didn‘t know that there are still so many nowadays. Totally crazy in my opinion. But I wasn‘t raised religiously and I grew up in Berlin. Maybe that are some of the reasons why it never mattered to me whether someone is gay, lesbian, bi, trans or straight. But QAF has definitely made me more aware of the problems of the LGTB community and I also try to talk a lot with my sons or answer questions so that no prejudices are built up. And since I'm addicted to Brian and Justin, I can‘t watch love movies about straight couples anymore... :-)

So, another perfect chapter! It‘s really heartbreaking to see Justin struggle so much with his fears and dark thoughts while babysitting Adeline. But what a beautiful end... „You did promise me" :-) Oh, I love your writing-style! Brian to the rescue! Phonesex with Brian while he's tricking relaxes and soothes Justin so much that he‘s able to sleep afterwards!

This scene with Justin, Brian and their "lesbians" is just amazing! You made me laugh and smile so much! I really love your idea, that they made new friends together. And Ana and Tori are just great!There are no prejudices and as you tell us through Justin‘s thoughts, there are no boxes. It still seems hard for Brian, but he seems to be more free, more relaxed and more open in this conversation, even if he backs off again at the end. But one shouldn‘t expect too much from Brian so fast...talking about love and relationships... :-) I love how you let him explain his meaning of „Sunshine" - so beautiful! And I agree with Ana and Tori... they love each other so much! And i really like that they can see through Brian‘s bullshit :-)

And yes, I think moving to LA would be a good idea, not only for whatever this is between them, but maybe it also would be a real first home for Justin, moving into something as whatever they are! Maybe Ana and Tori could follow soon... :-)

Thanks again for a fantastic chapter!

 



Author's Response:

To be very fair to my mother-in-law, her asking my wife to leave the house at 16 (my father-in-law didn't allow her to kick my wife out, so it could have been much worse) happened 24 years ago. She's since come around and went to protests for marriage equality before we had that here in the US and gave a lovely toast at our wedding. Things are much different from how they were back then although there are still far too many homeless LGBTQ youth. I'm so glad you will accept your kids no matter who they turn out to be or whom they love. 

I'm glad you, as a reader, are understanding why I introduced the original characters Ana and Tori. Being able to be around people who don't have the Kinney-mythic god status already ingrained in them allows both Brian and Justin to be more freely themselves. I think that's true for us all. Long standing friendships are a gift but sometimes it can be hard to grow and develop when someone has a particular idea of the type of person you are, even if that is very outdated. 

As for Ana and Tori following them... keep reading! (Ana and Tori are actually based on friends of mine so I'm especially glad you like them!) 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: Dec 02, 2019 8:11 pm Title: Chapter 10: Of Dreams and Nightmares

Just read your comment on my last review.... you mentioned S5... That's funny ... I wrote this a few hours ago...

Justin‘s reaction to Brian‘s question is so cute! And then their whole exchange the next morning. "Hey, I thought we said no phone numbers." - You let them be so beautiful, so cute together. I love them so much and that's exactly how I see them. And this "Sun-Justin". I know, since Ana's comment, he thinks, it puts too much pressure on Justin, but hey, Justin could be pouting the whole day or doing whatever, he is Brian's sunshine, his light - I don't know how to explain it... But I think it's cute that Brian tries to refrain. "And god, I would do..." This is so beautiful! And I can understand Brian's idea about LA - he always wanted to leave the Pitts and yeah, you described Justin as really happy there doing maybe for the first time something that makes him feel really useful, fulfilled, missing really only one thing, and that was Brian. And I think, okay, the family means well, but it would be also a chance for them and whatever "this" is between them to grow and develop without these constant interferences, which often led to rather negative results. But I like that they really think this through.

And then the scene with Molly is so heartbreaking, but I love how Brian handles it, comforting not only Justin but also Molly. And I never thought I would say that about tricking, (but as I wrote before, you let it seem so natural), it's so cute... "Can we have phone sex while a trick is giving me head?" I don't know what's going to happen, but at this point, your version of how it could have gone after LA is much more better than what they did with and out of them in S5. Again, thanks for this amazing story!



Author's Response:

I adore your view of Justin as "Sunshine" because he's Brian's light, not because he has to be happy all the time. 

I'll be honest that moving them to LA let me avoid having to write big scenes with tons of people in them - all that dialogue is hard! But I do think that the two of them leaving Pittsburgh would be good for their relationship so it made sense with the story too. 

I'm glad you think my story is better than S5 - I could have done without most of that season. It hurt so much!  

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 02, 2019 5:02 pm Title: Chapter 9: Advice Unsolicited

Hi! the weekend‘s over and so I‘ll slow down with reading and reviewing. But first, thanks very much for answering my reviews.

Monogamy: I totally agree with you, there are definately stressors in both monogamous and non-monogamous relationships. And no matter how one wants to live, I think the most important factor is honesty and that is one of the qualities that I so love about Brian. But I have to say, maybe until their „rules" Brian‘s tricking sometimes was hurtful or as I wrote to put Justin in his place (or maybe one could say Brian tried to protect himself from Justin :-) ) and in S5 I got the impression, Justin wasn‘t any longer so much into the tricking, and in my opinion the whole Brandon-thing was really pathetic and also disrespectful against Justin. But yeah, as I wrote before you are successful in „portraying non-monogamy in a good light" - they seem both to be content with it, it just seems natural.

So my hope was to make clear that Brian has this tough exterior he's had to develop to survive but underneath he's compassionate and generous, even if sometimes misguide" - You have succeeded in doing so, you characterize him in every case just as I see and love him. In my opinion you characterise them both soooo well and I just love their exchanges... also in this chapter... Alone this "Thank youuuuuu." For me, that's Justin (at least that playful part of him)!

Unfortunately, it was probably inevitable that they tell their "family.". Again, you‘ve described all the characters very well. Their reactions: Somehow their behavior makes me (once again) sad, on the other hand the way you write it, it‘s also hilarious. What I really find awful is that all of these comments to Brian really do support his thoughts that he's not good for Justin. Luckily it was only Daphne who was involved before! And as so often while watching the Show, I wonder where they get the right to judge: „C'mon Brian, it's not like the two of you talk" (Debbie) - "We just don't want to see the two of you fall apart because you're not communicating...again." (Michael) It's amazing, how you describe those characters so well!

But what a cute ending: "I grabbed an old pair of Justin's sweatpants" :-)



Author's Response:

Still appreciating all the thoughtful reviews!

I agree, early on in the series, Brian's tricking seemed to be partially to send a message to Justin but after the rules and as their relationship developed, it seemed and felt different at least to me. One of the reasons I had my series start with the beginning of S5 is that I felt things went off the rails a bit with Brian and Justin's relationship in S5. 

I'm so so so glad you feel my characterizations are accurate. I wanted to keep everyone in character and it's so hard! Both with imagining what they must be like in private when it's just the two of them and also having at least one character who is not upfront with his feelings make it difficult. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 01, 2019 6:23 pm Title: Chapter 8: 10 Minutes

Again, there are so many beautiful, cute and hilarious moments in this chapter!

I love this scene in the kitchen, cooking, swaying and humming together - so cute! But even after Brian‘s declaration of love (because that‘s what it was!) in the last chapter, Justin‘s still seems so be so insecure about his feelings. „caring moments demanded a certain non-reaction" - sad but true like so often in the show for example the whole zucchini-man-disaster. Those were the kind of tricking-scenes which I really hated to see in the Show, done just because of Brian‘s own insecurities and to put Justin in his place... Therefore, I really like the way you let them handle the tricking so far. They way you write it, it just seems natural, there is nothing hurtful about it and as long as both are content with it, why not... although, I must admit I like stories in which Brian not suddenly stop to trick but reduces it slowly until he realises he just don‘t need this kind of excitement or self-affirmation any longer... But I can totally understand that Justin is annoyed by these compassionate looks and lack of understanding of the others.

Oh, and then this hilarious scene with tori and the female version of Brian! Amazing! I really like your idea of them becoming friends together to people outside the normal circle.

Oh man, and as if Justin hasn't already enough to deal with, he has to listen to the shit Ben says, who thinks he knows about Justin and the reasons for the depression. I'm just glad, Justin made his point. Great chapter!

 



Author's Response:

Thank you again for such a thoughtful comment.

I certainly like fics where Brian and Justin are eventually monogamous but I'm never going to write that fic just because I love portraying non-monogamy in a good light. Sure there are stressors there but monogamous relationships have stressors too, just different ones. 

I'm excited for you to keep reading because you're going to see development on both their parts where they become more comfortable with each other and being secure in their relationship. Yes, when it comes to feelings, Brian will always be a little feral but he does mellow. Brian and Justin just have different ways of communicating that they love each other. They may not use the words, but they do (or will) know how they each feel. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: Dec 01, 2019 12:34 pm Title: Chapter 7: You'll Never Know, Dear

Oh my Goodness, I love this chapter! Again, so heartbreaking, so painful, but also so absolutely perfectly written. To imagine, Brian sitting in the car, calling Daphne, and all the stuff he‘s doing and thinking afterwards. I have no words, I think, the way you portray Brian, what he does, what he thinks is absolutely perfect. And I have already often thought so, not only Justin needs therapy, for Brian it would be also good. That he always wants to take the blame for everything. That he thinks, that because of his love and because he allows himself to be happy, dreadful things happen to Justin is just as fucked up as Justin's violent thoughts about Brian and Gus.

Luckily there is Daphne! I love the way you let her talk to Brian, setting him straight about some important things, making it clear to him what he had done really done to Justin with this departure („I knew you had a high opinion of yourself but, really, you are not that important or powerful." - even in this dramatic moment, you manage to make me laugh - that‘s one thing I really really so love aout your story and your writing-style).

And I love the way you let them talk! „This is it for me, kid" - Justin needed to hear those things Brian said and Brian also needed to hear that he finally has to stop making decisions for Justin. Wonderful, amazing chapter!



Author's Response:

Thank you, thank you, thank you.

It feels so good to read that what I meant to convey is landing with you. And yes, the humor is sprinkled in, because if I've learned anything, even in our most painful moments, we can also still laugh at the absurdity of life. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 01, 2019 8:38 am Title: Chapter 6: Left

My Goodness, so heartbreaking... it so very well written... one can feel Justin‘s pain, his dispair, his fear. Thanks god for Tori being there and her wisdom. At least she manages to calm Justin, giving him a little hope and first of all showing him the situation as it is. Sometimes we need something like that so as not to sink deeper into despair.

You have captured all the feelings so wonderful again. Amazing! Justin's desperation, but also Brian's. The fact that Brian calls Daphne right away shows only how much he loves Justin, that even at this moment of his own deep despair (he thinks he has to let Justin go because he isn‘t good for Justin), he thinks first of Justin and what he needs. Fortunately, Brian has given Daphne the reason why he couldn‘t stay with Justin. Even if Justin can‘t believe it at the moment, it's good he hears from Daphne that Brian didn‘t sound upset or angry but desperate and sad.

And thanks for this end of the chapter, thanks for not letting them suffering too long. It‘s so beautiful and cute, Justin lying in bed, wrapped in Brian‘s CMU hoddie, and Brian wearing an old paint-splattered t-shirts from Justin! Aewsome!



Author's Response:

Them wearing each other's clothes is a favorite thing of mine. And one of the benefits of a same sex relationship! 

I've always loved Daphne's character. She doesn't get to feature in my story as much as I would like but she does get this pivotal part. 

And yes, no matter what, Brian will make sure Justin is okay, even if he believes Justin being okay is to be apart from him. In the show, we see Brian sacrificing to ensure those he loves are happy and get what they need and it's just never really recognized. So my hope was to make clear that Brian has this tough exterior he's had to develop to survive but underneath he's compassionate and generous, even if sometimes misguided. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Dec 01, 2019 5:28 am Title: Chapter 5: Walk Away

While reading this shower scene, my heart was breaking for Brian. It‘s so obvious how crazy he‘s about Justin, he loves him so deeply... And I‘ve to admit, I couldn‘t stop reading and I‘ve the advantage, that your story‘s already finished, so I already know what‘ll happen, but you also gave us some hints here. And it‘s so typical Brian... „Justin is not violent", and therefore, if Justin‘s having such thoughts, Brian is to blame („Being with me cannot be what is best for a goddamn miracle like Justin.")... It's just a pity that he doesn‘t think about how his departure has to affect Justin at that moment. It‘s such a painful moment for both of them and again, my heart broke for them... Fantastic writing-style!



Author's Response:

Thank you again! I hope I'm not repetitive but your comments are so thoughtful and appreciated.

My heart broke writing that but sometimes pain is necessary for growth. And without pain, how can we truly appreciate happiness and joy? 

Brian, in my headcanon, never believed he was good enough for Justin so that will come through in my story, but he will also work through that to a large extent. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Nov 30, 2019 7:56 pm Title: Chapter 4: The Interview

Oh my goodness, altough I‘ve seen the Show over and over again, it‘s hard to read a summary of all the things Justin experienced, lived through and endured in the last five years - and that at an age of 17! I like that you also point out the factor that since getting kicked out from home he hasn‘t had his own home. Sure, the loft feels like home, but let‘s be honest, in the end it's Brian's, and Brian can decide if Justin stays or if he has to leave. He has no place to call his own where he can really feel safe and secure... that‘s why I love stories in which they‘re looking together for a new home or extend the loft to the floor below... Brian with red and puffy eyes - I also feel sorry for him, his concern for Justin must nearly kill him....



Author's Response:

Little hints that Brian is Feeling Things is a favorite of mine, since he rarely comes out and says anything. 

Justin basically being homeless except for the generosity of Debbie and Brian and Daphne (and Ethan for a moment) since he was 17 has always been such a difficult thing about his story arc that I don't think the show did justice to. Home, in its many meanings, is so important and where did Justin really feel at home during the show? It makes me sad just thinking about it. And too many queer youth have faced the same thing (my wife was nearly kicked out at 16 when she came out to her parents) and moany more of them don't have the good fortune (such that it was) that Justin did. 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Nov 30, 2019 5:03 pm Title: Chapter 3: 5150

 

What a heartbreaking but wonderful written chapter. I like your writing style so much. And in spite of this very serious and painful issue, I love, that there is also a sense of humor... „They're going to think I forgot to water you" - That sarcastic humor is one thing I love so much about Brian. Depending on the situation, he could be very hurtful in the show, but often also affectionate. Like in this case. In my opinion, you characterize him so well!

Poor Justin. I can‘t imagine this situation, to be hold in a locked unit for at least 72 hours not knowing what will happen. And I‘m also afraid about Brian‘s reaction when he gets more information about this „risk to others". And again, there are also so many beautiful and cute moments... the boyfriend-partner moment... the CMU hoodie moment... or Brian‘s behavior at the end of the chapter!



Author's Response:

I love Brian's sarcasm and I always think that it's possible for him to be loving, in a way Justin understands if no one else does, and still maintain that sense of humor. I hope throughout the story it's clear that both Brian and Justin grow and develop as characters but also retain who they are at the core. I love them both so much so I want to keep them in-character while still allowing for character development, which can be a hard balance to strike! 

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed [Report This]
Date: Nov 30, 2019 12:17 pm Title: Chapter 2: Back to Pitts

So, Justin‘s back. You have described his mood perfectly well and it‘s similar as in the show (at least at the beginning). This scene in the Diner where he pretends to be so content, to be back. And later, when he admits only to Brian, how great everything was there. When Brian asks him, why he should have even come back, and Justin says "Can‘t imagine", I got a little bit depressed myself, and felt very sorry for Brian. I also had the feeling that Justin had changed after his return, he was more serious, thoughtful, seemed partially to be lost. Therefore, your story really makes sense that these feelings and his previous experiences leads to a serious depression.

There are so many awesome aspects and little amazing details in your story, but I can‘t name all of them - the review would simply be too long. You have portrayed his feelings and his struggle so well especially those fears that something terrible might happen to other persons, and the guilt that it‘s happening now because you thought so. Fortunately, Brian has also recognized the changes and is looking for a conversation.

„I don't know if I had ever heard Brian speak in a paragraph before." :-)

I love the way you let them talk. Is good to see a Brian who confesses also his own fears. And I really love how you let Brian be so sensitive and attentive. Great chapter!



Author's Response:

Thank you again for such a thoghtful comment! 

I loe to imagine their relationship as it exists away from anyone else and I'm glad you're picking up on that. I think Brian is a natural caretaker (look at how amazing he was with Justin after the prom...well once Justin was living with him) and that will definitely come through in this story. 

You must login (register) to review.